CyclingNZ Home
Dramatic Positive Dope Test In US Re-Awakens Debates Over The Safety Of Nutritional Supplements
Date: 12 Dec, 2002
Contact: Brendan Quinn
So we’ve heard it all before. An athlete tests positive for an anabolic steroid, and he/she claims “it must have been in one of my supplements”, and we all go “yeah, or in your tea, or the town’s drinking water or something..get real!” Well now we have a REAL DEBATE on our hands with the very intelligent forethought of a (very successful) cyclist in the US, Scott Moninger. Having recently tested positive for 19-Norandrosterone, a precursor of an Anabolic Steroid, he went looking for answers from the supplements he was taking, not provided by any “under-the counter” source, like some guy in a long coat at the local gym driving a Cadillac…. no, bought legitimately from a retail source he and no doubt most people, believed to be reliable.

Only today we see another positive test (Spain, La Liga) in professional football, and the initiative taken by the Italian Football Federation to introduce BLOOD testing has to be praised highly.. but the emergence that supplements, as suggested by the IOC only 6 months ago may OFTEN be contaminated opens up a huge can of worms.

What do the teams’ dieticians do next? Ban all supplements? Even more so, what do the dope testers do next, nullify all recent positive tests in athletes using supplements known to be contaminated? (Think Jaap Stam, Pep Guardiola, Linford Christie, etc, etc) An even more difficult question will be who will advise and help the young amateur aspirant, probably the most important player in all sports: he or she with little or no income to pay for what are very expensive tests.. of EVERY SUPPLEMENT THEY MAY BE TAKING??

Of course the IOC and rules enforcement agencies can insist “if you’re positive, it’s your fault”, but this shows a severe lack of compassion for people whose livelihoods and success often depend on a large amount of trust in their circle of friends, coaches, managers and trainers.

Speaking personally as a Community Pharmacist I have seen, at first hand, the expense associated with independent testing and analysis of products, as well as the extreme levels of commercialism associated with the supplement, herbal and complimentary healthcare industries. Some Premiership (UK Soccer) clubs get over the risk by getting individual batches of supplements analysed and cleared before that batch (and ONLY that batch) is bought up for the team members. This is particularly useful in large volume supplements used frequently like Creatine. The costs associated with doing this for a young amateur cyclist/swimmer/hockey player etc would be impossible to justify at the schools level and age group.

In short, given that Moninger has SEALED bottles of his supplements available for testing, and those he had opened have already been proven positive for Steroid Contaminants, it would appear almost no supplement is safe, unless Pharmaceutically confirmed. Athletes will have to be even more careful, and should learn from Moninger who had the presence of mind to hold onto samples in sealed jars of the supplements he may yet blame for ruining his career. Most of my Community Pharmacist colleagues have indemnity insurance of up to 15 million Euro…I wonder how much indemnity various supplement manufacturers and retailers have?

Some advice for those athletes hell-bent on buying nutritional supplements:

• If you are really serious about your sport, is your supplement manufacturer willing to categorically PROVE their products contain no banned substances?

• Products in the UK and Ireland with a medical authorization have a PRODUCT LICENCE or PRODUCT AUTHORISATION number, which makes the manufacturer provide sufficient information to prove the purity and effectiveness of products. Many multivitamin supplements have this license (and many others have not) Unfortunately FEW of the rarer supplements like Co-Q10, Creatine, MSM or L-arginine have such licenses.

• If you are going to buy supplements, buy from a licensed retail outlet. (It would be interesting to see what sort of insurance they might have for ruining a career!)

• Try to get good nutrition from good food, and good nutritional advice from dieticians.

As a wise old sage once said…” even when you’re on the right road, you’ll still get run over if you sit there”..probably by a truckload of Nandrolone!

Brendan Quinn

Click to enlarge...

Latest News
Featuring new construction processes to bring an even lighter helmet by using new materials and less of them but taking the protective factor to new heights the engineers at MET have produced a winner with the Trenta and Trenta 3K Carbon helmets. Enhanced for use in the peloton, the MET Trenta’s >>
fi’zi:k are to supply world-class saddles to the best of the UCI WorldTour, with Team Sky, BMC Racing Team, Movistar Team, AG2R La Mondiale and Lotto NL-Jumbo on the 2018 roster. The quality of the squads and their ambitions for the forthcoming season should make for some highly entertaining >>
fi’zi:k are delighted to announce the roster of top-level riders who will be wearing the highly praised, award-winning R1B shoes throughout the 2017 season. The hit-list of Olympic, World and National Champions includes sprinters, climbers and puncheurs from across the globe, opting for the >>
Latest Articles
The 2018 Downhill and Cross Country World Cups came to a climax this weekend with the final round of racing in France. We saw great season-ending placings for Fizik saddle riders: Loris Vergier took 4th and Luca Shaw 8th in the Downhill, while Lars Forster 4th, Stephane Tempier 6th and Titouan >>
Tour de France champion Geraint Thomas and Giro d’Italia winner Chris Froome will ride together in the OVO Energy Tour of Britain for the first time since 2009, Team Sky have announced today. The British pair, who placed first and third in July’s Tour de France, will both be on the start >>
After only a month back on the bike after fracturing his back in a collision with a car in late January Southlander Corbin Strong won today’s elite men’s 139 kilometre race in round four of the Calder Stewart Cycling Series in Timaru. One of New Zealand's most promising young cyclists, 18 >>
LOOK 2018
Morgan Blue Cleaning
ISM Saddles
 Photo Gallery
Tour de Femme Daniel Gate bioSPORT Crite
Mike NortheybioSPORT Series Champion Tour de Femme
Home Kiwi Riders Sports Science Beginners Articles Riders Reports Tech Corner Contact
© 2019 | Login | Design by OnfireDesign